NYC › Upper West Side (Central) › Jake's Dilemma
Jake's Dilemma
american, alcoholic beverage bar, bar, pub · bar · 430 Amsterdam Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10024
Full liquor license (NY State Liquor Authority 0370-24-133078, valid until 2026-10-31). NYC Health grade A (since 2025-10-28). Outdoor dining permit: sidewalk (valid until 2030-04-17). Last recorded change: 2026-04-17.
Key facts
- Health grade
- A (current status since 2025-10-28; last inspected 2025-10-28, 1 critical violation(s) at last inspection) [official record]
- Alcohol
- Full liquor license [official record: licensed to serve; not proof of what's on the menu]
- Outdoor dining
- City permit: sidewalk [official record: permission, not proof tables are out today]
- Reservations
- unknown
- Online ordering
- unknown
- Price range
- unknown
- Phone
- (212) 580-0556
- Website
- unknown
- Menu
- unknown
Dietary
- vegan
- unknown
- vegetarian
- unknown
- gluten free
- unknown
- halal
- unknown
- kosher
- unknown
Features
- private dining
- unknown
- happy hour
- unknown
- brunch
- unknown
- live music
- unknown
- kids menu
- unknown
- wheelchair accessible
- unknown
- dog friendly
- unknown
- byob
- unknown
- cash only
- unknown
- walk ins
- unknown
- catering
- unknown
- gift cards
- unknown
All facts and evidence
| Fact | Value | Evidence type | Evidence | Source | Dates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| alcohol | full_bar | official record | Additional Bar license 0370-24-133078-02 (JAKE'S DILEMMA), expires 10/31/2026; Additional Bar license 0370-24-133078-01 (JAKE'S DILEMMA), expires 10/31/2026; Food & Beverage Business license 0370-24-133078 (JAKE'S DILEMMA), expires 10/31/2026 | nys_sla | source date 2024-10-24 valid until 2026-10-31 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| category | {"hierarchy": ["food_and_drink", "alcoholic_beverage_venue", "bar", "pub"], "primary": "pub"} | directory category | Overture place ff8bf370-0cc9-417e-88e6-d5705df6614f (Jake's Dilemma), match score 3.00, 16m | overture | source date 2026-09-26 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| cuisine dohmh | American | directory category | Cuisine category as registered with NYC Health Dept | dohmh | source date 2026-09-25 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| health grade | A | official record | Letter grade A issued 2025-10-28 | dohmh | source date 2025-10-28 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| health status | {"critical_violations_last_inspection": 1, "last_inspection": "2025-10-28", "last_score": 13, "status": "A", "status_date": "2025-10-28"} | official record | Last inspected 2025-10-28, score 13; latest grade status A (grade A) on 2025-10-28; critical: Filth flies or food/refuse/sewage associated with (FRSA) flies or other nuisance pests in establishment’s food and/or non-food areas. FRSA flies include house f | dohmh | source date 2025-10-28 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| outdoor seating | ["sidewalk"] | official record | Sidewalk cafe license issued 2026-04-17, expires 2030-04-17 (JAKE'S DILEMMA, 430 AMSTERDAM AVENUE) | dining_out_nyc | source date 2026-04-17 valid until 2030-04-17 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
| website unverified | http://www.nycbestbars.com/JD.htm | directory category | Overture place ff8bf370-0cc9-417e-88e6-d5705df6614f (Jake's Dilemma), match score 3.00, 16m; domain does not resemble the business name, so it is not used | overture | source date 2026-09-26 retrieved 2026-09-26 |
History
| Date | What changed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-04-17 | Outdoor dining permit added: ['sidewalk'] Sidewalk cafe license issued 2026-04-17, expires 2030-04-17 (JAKE'S DILEMMA, 430 AMSTERDAM AVENUE) | dining_out_nyc |
| 2025-08-20 | Liquor license added: full_bar License 0370-24-133078 originally issued 2025-08-20 | nys_sla |
| 2024-10-24 | Liquor license added: full_bar License 0370-24-133078-01 originally issued 2024-10-24 | nys_sla |
| 2024-10-24 | Liquor license added: full_bar License 0370-24-133078-02 originally issued 2024-10-24 | nys_sla |
| 2023-10-11 | Health grade added: A Graded A by NYC Health Dept on 2023-10-11 | dohmh |
Verify elsewhere
Last recorded change 2026-04-17 · page generated 2026-09-26 (sources are re-checked weekly; see each fact's dates) · id nyc-40401453 · JSON